Editorial Playlist Pitching Masterclass: Complete Guide

Audience: All Audiences | Read time: 14 min | Last updated: January 2026
​

A single editorial playlist placement can generate hundreds of thousands of streams. Major Spotify playlists receive 500-2,000 submissions daily, and curators have approximately 15-30 seconds to evaluate each track. Most pitches fail because they don't understand what editorial teams actually evaluate.
​

This guide covers what makes a strong pitch, the metrics curators use to make decisions, platform-specific strategies, and what to do when you don't receive placement.

Understanding the curator's perspective transforms how you approach playlist pitching. Curators aren't fighting against algorithms; they're working with them. Tracks that perform well algorithmically have already proven their commercial viability, making curator placement safer and more predictable.

Playlists exist to serve streaming platforms' business goals: user engagement, retention, and satisfaction. Curators succeed when their playlist selections keep listeners engaged, not when they champion artistic integrity over performance metrics.

This means the common belief that curators pick songs they personally love is largely inaccurate. In practice, curators pick songs that data shows listeners will love. Performance metrics matter more than label affiliation or industry relationships.

1. Completion Rate: The Quality Indicator

Completion rate measures the percentage of listeners who play your song from start to finish without skipping. High completion rates predict playlist retention. If listeners skip your song on a playlist, it damages the playlist's overall performance.

Curator benchmarks for completion rate:

To find your completion rate in Spotify for Artists: Navigate to Music tab, select your song, and look for "Listeners who played till the end." Calculate: (Completed plays divided by Total plays) multiplied by 100.

2. Save-to-Stream Ratio: The Engagement Signal

Save rate measures how often listeners save your song to their library after hearing it. Saves indicate genuine connection beyond passive listening and predict long-term streaming success.

Curator expectations for save rate:

Calculate your save rate: (Total Saves divided by Total Streams) multiplied by 100. A track with 50,000 streams and 1,800 saves has a 3.6% save rate, meeting the editorial consideration threshold.

3. Skip Patterns: The Quality Diagnostic

Curators analyze where in your song listeners skip and how quickly skipping occurs. Skip patterns reveal specific song problems and predict playlist performance issues.

Skip rate targets:

High skip rates in the first 30 seconds indicate weak hooks. Mid-song skips suggest energy drops or structural problems. Late skips often indicate unsatisfying endings.

4. Audience Quality Indicators

Beyond individual song metrics, curators evaluate your overall audience quality:

Strong audience quality signals that you have engaged fans who will stream songs repeatedly, improving playlist performance.

5. Growth Trajectory

Curators prefer artists showing momentum. Month-over-month growth in listeners, followers, and engagement demonstrates that adding you to a playlist will contribute to the playlist's overall trajectory, not just benefit you.

Editorial teams receive thousands of pitches filled with generic marketing language. Phrases like "rising artist with millions of streams across platforms" blend into noise. What stands out is a clear, compelling story about this specific song.

Weak pitch: "Rising artist with millions of streams across platforms. This track showcases our signature sound and production style. Perfect for any playlist."

Strong pitch: "I wrote this song the night my grandmother passed. It's about finding peace with loss, something I think a lot of people are processing right now. The production builds from a single piano to a full arrangement, mirroring the journey from grief to acceptance."

The strong pitch gives the curator something to connect with emotionally and provides context for why the song matters beyond its sonic qualities.

Vague claims like "fits chill playlists" or "perfect for workout playlists" demonstrate no understanding of specific playlist curation. Curators want evidence you've researched their playlists and understand why your song belongs.

Weak pitch: "Would fit any indie playlist. The sound is very indie and alternative."

Strong pitch: "The atmospheric production and vulnerable lyrics match the mood of 'Late Night Feelings.' My song would sit well between Phoebe Bridgers and Bon Iver on that playlist. The tempo (82 BPM) and instrumentation align with the playlist's signature sound."

The strong pitch names a specific playlist, identifies comparable artists already on that playlist, and provides concrete details about why the song fits.

Data-driven submissions outperform relationship-based pitches. Instead of generic artist descriptions, lead with metrics that demonstrate your track meets editorial standards.

Example data-driven pitch opening:

"'Ocean Waves' by [Artist Name] is performing at editorial playlist levels:

Performance Data:

Audience Quality:

This approach demonstrates that you understand what curators evaluate and provides evidence that your track will perform well on their playlist.

What's happening around this release? Curators consider factors beyond the music itself:

This context helps curators understand whether adding your song will be supported by external activity that drives additional streams.

Submission process: Pitch through Spotify for Artists at least 7 days before release. Earlier is better, up to 4 weeks. Pitching is only available for unreleased music.

What Spotify values:

Algorithm relationship: Spotify's editorial decisions work alongside algorithmic signals. Strong performance on Discover Weekly and Release Radar often precedes editorial consideration. Build algorithmic success first, then pursue editorial placement.

Key metrics Spotify weighs: Save rate (strongest signal), completion rate, repeat listens, playlist adds, and skip rate. When these signals are strong in the first 24-48 hours, the algorithm expands distribution.

Submission process: Apple Music editorial pitching typically happens through label or distributor connections. If you have a distributor with editorial relationships, use their pitching tools. Submit 4+ weeks before release.

What Apple values:

Key difference from Spotify: Apple Music is more editorial and human-driven than Spotify's pure algorithmic approach. Relationships with the Apple Music team matter more, and submissions benefit from label or distributor advocacy.

Shazam optimization: Since Shazam data influences Apple Music editorial decisions, consider how discoverable your track is in real-world situations. Tracks played in retail environments, gyms, or public spaces that generate Shazam searches demonstrate organic discovery appeal.

Submission process: Submit through Deezer for Creators. Focus on market-specific editorial teams in Deezer's strong territories.

What Deezer values:

Geographic targeting: If your music resonates in Deezer's strong markets, specifically target those regional editorial teams. A track performing well with French listeners has better odds on French Deezer playlists than on global Deezer features.

Submission process: Submit through Amazon Music for Artists. Include complete metadata and high-quality assets.

What Amazon values:

Strategic opportunity: Amazon Music's editorial team is smaller and receives fewer submissions than Spotify or Apple. Including Amazon in your pitch strategy, especially for genre-specific playlists, offers better odds than focusing exclusively on larger platforms.

4-6 weeks before release: Ideal submission window. Editorial teams plan weeks in advance, and early submissions receive more thorough consideration.

2-3 weeks before release: Still viable for consideration, but reduced odds as playlist programming may already be set.

7 days before release: Minimum lead time for Spotify for Artists submission. Later submissions significantly reduce editorial consideration chances.

Based on curator activity patterns:

Before submitting, spend 60-90 days optimizing your metrics:

Days 1-30: Completion Rate Optimization

Days 31-60: Save Rate Enhancement

Days 61-90: Audience Quality Development

Rather than targeting only major editorial playlists, implement a pyramid approach:

Target the highest-profile playlists in your genre:

These have the lowest acceptance rates but highest potential impact.

Target playlists with significant reach but less competition:

Build playlist presence through community curators:

Community playlist success provides data and credibility for editorial submissions.

Independent curators control user-generated playlists with significant followings. Building relationships with these curators provides sustained discovery beyond editorial placement.

Study each curator's playlists before reaching out:

Subject: [Genre] Artist Submission - [Song Title]

Hi [Curator Name],

I've been following [Playlist Name] and really appreciate your curation of [specific artists or songs you've noticed]. The way you blend [specific observation] creates a great listening experience.

I'm [Artist Name], a [genre] artist from [location]. My latest single "[Song Title]" explores [brief theme] with [production style]. I think it would fit well with tracks like [specific songs from their playlist].

Key details:

I've attached a brief one-sheet with more details. Would love to know if this fits your playlist vision.

Thank you for supporting independent artists.

[Your Name]

Playlist relationships work best as ongoing partnerships, not transactional submissions:

Most songs don't receive editorial placement. Industry data suggests editorial playlist acceptance rates are well below 5% for most submissions. This is normal, not a reflection of your music's quality.

Strong early engagement triggers Release Radar and Discover Weekly inclusion without editorial intervention:

Release Radar optimization:

Discover Weekly optimization:

While editorial placement is difficult, independent curator relationships are more accessible:

Songs can receive playlist placement months or years after release. A song that didn't fit current editorial programming may align with future playlist needs:

Each submission provides learning opportunities:

You can only pitch unreleased songs through Spotify for Artists. Once a song is released, editorial pitching through the official channel closes. However, released songs can still be added to playlists if curators discover them through other means, including independent curator outreach.

Paid playlist placement services carry significant risks. Many violate platform terms of service, use bot-driven playlists that damage your algorithmic signals, or simply don't deliver promised results. Legitimate promotional spending goes toward advertising, PR, and content creation that drives organic streams, not purchased placements.

Focus on song structure optimization before submitting. Analyze where listeners skip, strengthen hooks in the first 15 seconds, maintain energy consistency throughout the track, and consider song length optimization (2:30-3:30 performs best). Submitting tracks with poor completion rates wastes your pitch and may harm future consideration.

Follower count matters less than follower quality. Curators evaluate follower conversion rate (what percentage of listeners become followers), not raw numbers. An artist with 1,000 followers and 20% follower conversion demonstrates stronger audience connection than an artist with 10,000 followers and 2% conversion.

Yes. Songs can be added to playlists months or years after release. Seasonal playlists, mood playlists, and genre-specific playlists regularly feature catalog tracks. Keep your metadata optimized, continue improving metrics on existing songs, and maintain relationships with curators who may feature older music.

Before your next release, write your pitch story. What's the one thing that makes this song worth caring about? What metrics demonstrate that your existing audience engages deeply? What specific playlists fit your sound, and why?

Start with story, not stream counts. Then support that story with data that proves your track will perform well on a curator's playlist.

Use AndR to track your completion rates, save rates, and audience quality metrics across your catalog. Understanding which songs perform at editorial standards helps you identify what works and apply those insights to future releases.

Spotify for Artists Editorial Guidelines. Official guidance on pitching to Spotify editorial playlists, including best practices, timeline recommendations, and submission requirements. Available at artists.spotify.com.

Apple Music for Artists Resources. Documentation on Apple Music editorial consideration, Shazam integration, and platform optimization. Available at artists.apple.com.

Music Business Worldwide Playlist Coverage. Industry analysis of playlist trends, editorial changes, and streaming platform developments affecting playlist strategy.

This article is part of the AndR knowledge base. Use AndR to monitor your completion rates, save rates, and playlist performance across your catalog to identify editorial-ready tracks.